Sat Jul 19 2025, by Tyler Gardner

401kRetirement PlanningWealth ManagementFinancial LiteracyInvestment Strategy

The 401k Match is Overhyped: Here’s Why

I'm Tyler, a former financial advisor and portfolio manager. If any of this is helpful, sign up for my free newsletter by clicking the link in my bio.

1. It’s Free Money, but Not a Magic Button

Yes, the match is essentially free money. However, people treat it like a magic button, assuming that simply hitting that 6% match means they’re done. Spoiler: that's not going to fund your retirement unless you're planning on living off of lentils.

2. Expensive and Outdated Investment Options

Most 401k plans are full of expensive and outdated mutual funds. If you're paying 1% or 2% in fees, that free money comes with a very expensive string attached.

3. Lack of Liquidity and Control

There’s no liquidity, not as much control, and no access to your funds until age 59 ½. To be clear, I'm not telling you to skip it. Just don’t act like it’s the finish line. A 401k is a tool, not a trophy.

4. Focus on Building Real Wealth

Max the match, but don't let it distract you from building real wealth on your own terms as well.

Source